Original Research

Assessing the effectiveness of invasive alien plant management in a large fynbos protected area

Tineke Kraaij, Johan A. Baard, Diba R. Rikhotso, Nicholas S. Cole, Brian W. van Wilgen
Bothalia | Vol 47, No 2 | a2105 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.4102/abc.v47i2.2105 | © 2017 Tineke Kraaij, Johan A. Baard, Diba R. Rikhotso, Nicholas S. Cole, Brian W. van Wilgen | This work is licensed under CC Attribution 4.0
Submitted: 31 May 2016 | Published: 31 March 2017

About the author(s)

Tineke Kraaij, School of Natural Resource Management, Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University, South Africa
Johan A. Baard, Scientific Services, South African National Parks, South Africa
Diba R. Rikhotso, Scientific Services, South African National Parks, South Africa
Nicholas S. Cole, Biodiversity Social Projects, South African National Parks, South Africa
Brian W. van Wilgen, Centre for Invasion Biology, Department of Botany and Zoology, University of Stellenbosch, South Africa

Abstract

Background: Concern has been expressed about the effectiveness of invasive alien plant (IAP) control operations carried out by Working for Water (WfW). South African legislation now also requires reporting on the effectiveness of IAP management interventions.
Objectives: We assessed the effectiveness of IAP management practices in a large fynbos protected area, the Garden Route National Park, South Africa.
Methods: We undertook field surveys of pre-clearing IAP composition and the quality of treatments applied by WfW during 2012–2015 in 103 management units, covering 4280 ha. We furthermore assessed WfW data for evidence of change in IAP cover after successive treatments, and adherence to industry norms.
Results: Despite the development of detailed management plans, implementation was poorly aligned with plans. The quality of many treatments was inadequate, with work done to standard in only 23% of the assessed area. Problems encountered included (1) a complete absence of treatment application despite the payment of contractors (33% of assessed area); (2) treatments not being comprehensive in that select areas (38%), IAP species (11%) or age classes (8%) were untreated; (3) wrong choice of treatment method (9%); and (4) treatments not applied to standard (7%). Accordingly, successive follow-up treatments largely did not reduce the cover of IAPs. Inaccurate (or lack of) infield estimation of IAP cover prior to contract generation resulted in erroneous estimation of effort required and expenditure disparate with WfW norms.
Conclusions: We advocate rigorous, compulsory, infield assessment of IAP cover prior to contract allocation and assessment of the quality of treatments applied prior to contractors’ payment. This should improve the efficiency of control operations and enable tracking of both the state of invasions and effectiveness of management.

Keywords

conservation agencies; effectiveness; implementation; industry norms and standards; interventions; monitoring; project management; weed clearing; Working for Water

Metrics

Total abstract views: 4875
Total article views: 6494

 

Crossref Citations

1. Identifying potential distributions of 10 invasive alien trees: implications for conservation management of protected areas
Ji-Zhong Wan, Zhi-Xiang Zhang, Chun-Jing Wang
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment  vol: 190  issue: 12  year: 2018  
doi: 10.1007/s10661-018-7104-6

2. Indicators for monitoring biological invasions at a national level
John R. U. Wilson, Katelyn T. Faulkner, Sebataolo J. Rahlao, David M. Richardson, Tsungai A. Zengeya, Brian W. van Wilgen, Céline Bellard
Journal of Applied Ecology  vol: 55  issue: 6  first page: 2612  year: 2018  
doi: 10.1111/1365-2664.13251

3. Research note: Trail runners as agents of alien plant introduction into protected areas
Kyle Smith, Tineke Kraaij
Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism  vol: 31  first page: 100315  year: 2020  
doi: 10.1016/j.jort.2020.100315

4. Stakeholder Perspectives on the Current Decision‐Making Process of Invasive Alien Plant Management
Current Masunungure, Agripa Ngorima, Amanda Manyani, Mwazvita T. B. Dalu, Tatenda Dalu
African Journal of Ecology  vol: 63  issue: 5  year: 2025  
doi: 10.1111/aje.70075

5. The dominating influence of efficacy above management strategy in the long-term success of alien plant clearing programmes
Chad Cheney, Karen J. Esler, Llewellyn C. Foxcroft, Nicola J. van Wilgen
Journal of Environmental Management  vol: 271  first page: 110836  year: 2020  
doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2020.110836

6. Ecological restoration of ecosystems degraded by invasive alien plants in South African Fynbos: Is spontaneous succession a viable strategy?
Patricia M. Holmes, Karen J. Esler, Brian W. van Wilgen, David M. Richardson
Transactions of the Royal Society of South Africa  vol: 75  issue: 2  first page: 111  year: 2020  
doi: 10.1080/0035919X.2020.1781291

7. Economic evaluation of chemical and biological control of four aquatic weeds in South Africa
Mary Maluleke, Gavin C. G. Fraser, Martin P. Hill
Biocontrol Science and Technology  vol: 31  issue: 9  first page: 896  year: 2021  
doi: 10.1080/09583157.2021.1900783

8. An assessment of climate, weather, and fuel factors influencing a large, destructive wildfire in the Knysna region, South Africa
Tineke Kraaij, Johan A. Baard, Jacob Arndt, Lufuno Vhengani, Brian W. van Wilgen
Fire Ecology  vol: 14  issue: 2  year: 2018  
doi: 10.1186/s42408-018-0001-0

9. Scenarios for the management of invasive Acacia species in a protected area: Implications of clearing efficacy
Chad Cheney, Karen J. Esler, Llewellyn C. Foxcroft, Nicola J. van Wilgen
Journal of Environmental Management  vol: 238  first page: 274  year: 2019  
doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2019.02.112

10. Community narratives and local impacts of invasion in the Eastern Cape: A critical invasion ethnography of black wattle
Jules M Reynolds
Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space  vol: 5  issue: 3  first page: 1639  year: 2022  
doi: 10.1177/25148486211020855

11. Preliminary Evidence of Foliar Spray Effectiveness Against the Invasive Cactus Cylindropuntia pallida (Rose), F.M. Knuth in South Africa
Keletso Makaota, Thabiso Michael Mokotjomela, Caswell Munyai, Thembelihle Joyce Mbele, Nontembeko Dube
International Journal of Plant Biology  vol: 16  issue: 4  first page: 113  year: 2025  
doi: 10.3390/ijpb16040113

12. Determining the Spectral Characteristics of Fynbos Wetland Vegetation Species Using Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Data
Kevin Musungu, Moreblessings Shoko, Julian Smit
Geomatics  vol: 5  issue: 2  first page: 17  year: 2025  
doi: 10.3390/geomatics5020017

13. Contributions to the National Status Report on Biological Invasions in South Africa
John R.U. Wilson, Mirijam Gaertner, David M. Richardson, Brian W. Van Wilgen
Bothalia  vol: 47  issue: 2  year: 2017  
doi: 10.4102/abc.v47i2.2207

14. Use of a rapid roadside survey to detect potentially invasive plant species along the Garden Route, South Africa
Johan A. Baard, Tineke Kraaij
Koedoe  vol: 61  issue: 1  year: 2019  
doi: 10.4102/koedoe.v61i1.1515

15. Biological invasions in South African National Parks
Llewellyn C. Foxcroft, Nicola J. Van Wilgen, Johan A. Baard, Nicholas S. Cole
Bothalia  vol: 47  issue: 2  year: 2017  
doi: 10.4102/abc.v47i2.2158

16. An assessment of the evolution, costs and effectiveness of alien plant control operations in Kruger National Park, South Africa
Brian W. van Wilgen, Jennifer M. Fill, Navashni Govender, Llewellyn C. Foxcroft
NeoBiota  vol: 35  first page: 35  year: 2017  
doi: 10.3897/neobiota.35.12391

17. Assessing the environmental impacts of invasive alien plants: a review of assessment approaches
Robert Bartz, Ingo Kowarik
NeoBiota  vol: 43  first page: 69  year: 2019  
doi: 10.3897/neobiota.43.30122

18. A review of two decades of government support for managing alien plant invasions in South Africa
Brian W. van Wilgen, Andrew Wannenburgh, John R.U. Wilson
Biological Conservation  vol: 274  first page: 109741  year: 2022  
doi: 10.1016/j.biocon.2022.109741

19. Progress towards the control of invasive alien species in the Cape Floristic Region’s protected areas
Brian W. van Wilgen, Nicholas S. Cole, Johan Baard, Chad Cheney, Karen Engelbrecht, Louise Stafford, Andrew A. Turner, Nicola J. van Wilgen, Andrew M. Wannenburgh
Biological Invasions  vol: 27  issue: 1  year: 2025  
doi: 10.1007/s10530-024-03459-3

20. A new protocol for monitoring operational outcomes of environmental management in commercial forestry plantations
L. Joubert-van der Merwe, M.J. Samways, J.S. Pryke
Journal of Environmental Management  vol: 271  first page: 110922  year: 2020  
doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2020.110922

21. The Economic Implications ofRobinia pseudoacaciaL. (black locust) on Agricultural Production in South Africa
Luke Humphrey, Gavin Fraser, Grant Martin
Agrekon  vol: 58  issue: 2  first page: 216  year: 2019  
doi: 10.1080/03031853.2019.1580591

22. Quantifying range structure to inform management in invaded landscapes
Chad Cheney, Nicola J. van Wilgen, Karen J. Esler, Llewellyn C. Foxcroft, Melodie A. McGeoch, Anibal Pauchard
Journal of Applied Ecology  vol: 58  issue: 2  first page: 338  year: 2021  
doi: 10.1111/1365-2664.13765

23. Using the analytic hierarchical process to identify potential sites for rural ecological infrastructure investment in South Africa: examples from Cacadu and Tsitsa Catchments
B. Sinetemba Xoxo, Sukhmani K. Mantel, Alta De Vos, Jane L. Tanner, David C. Le Maître
Restoration Ecology  vol: 33  issue: 2  year: 2025  
doi: 10.1111/rec.14198

24. Optimal Temporal Windows for Mapping Fynbos Seep Wetlands Using Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Data
Kevin Musungu, Moreblessings Shoko, Julian Smit
Geographies  vol: 5  issue: 4  first page: 60  year: 2025  
doi: 10.3390/geographies5040060