Original Research

The handling of the proposal to conserve the name Acacia at the 17th International Botanical Congress—an attempt at minority rule

G. Moore
Bothalia | Vol 37, No 1 | a308 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.4102/abc.v37i1.308 | © 2007 G. Moore | This work is licensed under CC Attribution 4.0
Submitted: 15 August 2007 | Published: 18 August 2007

About the author(s)

G. Moore, Brooklyn Botanic Garden, United States

Full Text:

PDF (1006KB)

Abstract

The handling of controversial Proposal 1584 to conserve the name Acacia with a conserved type for the Australian acacias during the Nomenclature Section meeting at the 17th International Botanical Congress (Vienna) in 2005 is reviewed. Through a simple majority vote, this Section adopted rules requiring a 60% majority of votes to approve any proposal to modify the International Code of Botanical Nomenclature and a simple majority to approve all other motions; motions not receiving the required majority were to be rejected. However, for the motion addressing Proposal 1584, 45.1% voted to conserve the type of the name Acacia for Australian acacias, and 54.9% voted to retain the current African type for the name Acacia. Even though this motion failed to get a 60% majority either way as required by the Section’s own rules, Section officials have concluded that the name Acacia is to be conserved for Australian acacias. Treating a motion as approved, even though it received only minority support, also violates the fundamental principle of standard parliamentary procedure—the right of the majority to approve proposals. For Acacia to be formally conserved, the Nomenclature Section needed to approve a motion addressing Proposal 1584 with a majority vote, and this never happened in Vienna. Recommendations are made on how this process might be improved.


Keywords

<i>Acacia</i>, conservation, International Botanical Congress, International Code of Botanical Nomenclature, nomenclature. Nomenclature Section, Racosperma C.Mart., Senegalia Raf., <i>Vachellia</i> W.F.Wight & Am

Metrics

Total abstract views: 4152
Total article views: 2398

 

Crossref Citations

1. Evolutionary and taxonomic relationships of Acacia s.l. (Leguminosae: Mimosoideae)
Joseph T. Miller, David Seigler
Australian Systematic Botany  vol: 25  issue: 3  first page: 217  year: 2012  
doi: 10.1071/SB11042

2. Plant‐ants use resistance‐related plant odours to assess host quality before colony founding
Rosario Razo‐Belman, Jorge Molina‐Torres, Octavio Martínez, Martin Heil, David Edwards
Journal of Ecology  vol: 106  issue: 1  first page: 379  year: 2018  
doi: 10.1111/1365-2745.12832

3. ВАЖНЕЙШИЕ РЕШЕНИЯ НОМЕНКЛАТУРНОЙ СЕКЦИИ XVIII МЕЖДУНАРОДНОГО БОТАНИЧЕСКОГО КОНГРЕССА (МЕЛЬБУРН, 18-22 ИЮЛЯ 2011 Г.), "БОТАНИЧЕСКИЙ ЖУРНАЛ"
Д.В. ГЕЛЬТМАН
Ботанический журнал  issue: 2  first page: 282  year: 2012  
doi: 10.1134/S1234567812020140

4. Taxonomic imperialism in the battles forAcacia: Identity and science in South Africa and Australia
Jane Carruthers, Libby Robin
Transactions of the Royal Society of South Africa  vol: 65  issue: 1  first page: 48  year: 2010  
doi: 10.1080/00359191003652066

5. Neotropical mutualism between Acacia and Pseudomyrmex: Phylogeny and divergence times
Sandra Gómez-Acevedo, Lourdes Rico-Arce, Alfonso Delgado-Salinas, Susana Magallón, Luis E. Eguiarte
Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution  vol: 56  issue: 1  first page: 393  year: 2010  
doi: 10.1016/j.ympev.2010.03.018

6. Lectotypification in AmericanAcaciaspecies (Fabaceae, Mimosoideae), with Clarifications for Types at the Muséum national d'Histoire naturelle
David Seigler, John E. Ebinger, Cécile Aupic, Gérard G. Aymonin, Caroline Loup
Novon: A Journal for Botanical Nomenclature  vol: 23  issue: 1  first page: 98  year: 2014  
doi: 10.3417/2010021

7. Apportionment of institutional votes for the Nomenclature Section: A rebuttal to Smith & al.
Wendy L. Applequist, Martin W. Callmander, Gerrit Davidse, Alexander Sennikov, Mats Thulin, Piet Vorster, George Yatskievych
TAXON  vol: 59  issue: 5  first page: 1567  year: 2010  
doi: 10.1002/tax.595020

8. The Acacia controversy resulting from minority rule at the Vienna Nomenclature Section: Much more than arcane arguments and complex technicalities
Gerry Moore, Gideon F. Smith, Estrela Figueiredo, Sebsebe Demissew, Gwilym Lewis, Brian Schrire, Lourdes Rico, Abraham E. van Wyk, Melissa Luckow, Roberto Kiesling, Mario Sousa S.
TAXON  vol: 60  issue: 3  first page: 852  year: 2011  
doi: 10.1002/tax.603017

9. Who amends the International code of botanical nomenclature?
Gideon F. Smith, Estrela Figueiredo, Gerry Moore
TAXON  vol: 59  issue: 3  first page: 930  year: 2010  
doi: 10.1002/tax.593021

10. The conservation of Acacia with A. penninervis as conserved type
John McNeill, Nicholas J. Turland
TAXON  vol: 59  issue: 2  first page: 613  year: 2010  
doi: 10.1002/tax.592026

11. Salvia united: The greatest good for the greatest number
Bryan T. Drew, Jesús Guadalupe González-Gallegos, Chun-Lei Xiang, Ricardo Kriebel, Chloe P. Drummond, Jay B. Walked, Kenneth J. Sytsma
TAXON  vol: 66  issue: 1  first page: 133  year: 2017  
doi: 10.12705/661.7

12. A phylogenetic solution to the Acacia problem
Joseph T. Miller, David Seigler, Brent D. Mishler
TAXON  vol: 63  issue: 3  first page: 653  year: 2014  
doi: 10.12705/633.2

13. Synoptic Overview of Exotic Acacia, Senegalia and Vachellia (Caesalpinioideae, Mimosoid Clade, Fabaceae) in Egypt
Rania A. Hassan, Rim S. Hamdy
Plants  vol: 10  issue: 7  first page: 1344  year: 2021  
doi: 10.3390/plants10071344

14. In defense of the primacy of the Nomenclature Section in decision‐making in botanical nomenclature: A reply to the Rapporteurs’ comment on Proposal 193 to amend the Shenzhen Code
Gerry Moore, Gideon F. Smith, Estrela Figueiredo, Leslie R. Landrum, Roy E. Gereau, Jefferson Prado, Sebsebe Demissew, Wendy Applequist, Alejandro Quintanar, Renée Fortunato, Alina Freire‐Fierro, Jun Wen, Yun‐Fei Deng
TAXON  vol: 73  issue: 3  first page: 663  year: 2024  
doi: 10.1002/tax.13182

15. The evolution and phylogenetic placement of invasive AustralianAcaciaspecies
Joseph T. Miller, Daniel J. Murphy, Gillian K. Brown, David M. Richardson, Carlos E. González‐Orozco
Diversity and Distributions  vol: 17  issue: 5  first page: 848  year: 2011  
doi: 10.1111/j.1472-4642.2011.00780.x

16. A native at home and abroad: the history, politics, ethics and aesthetics of acacias
Jane Carruthers, Libby Robin, Johan P. Hattingh, Christian A. Kull, Haripriya Rangan, Brian W. van Wilgen
Diversity and Distributions  vol: 17  issue: 5  first page: 810  year: 2011  
doi: 10.1111/j.1472-4642.2011.00779.x

17. Acacia, the 2011 Nomenclature Section in Melbourne, and beyond
Gerry Moore, Gideon F. Smith, Estrela Figueiredo, Sebsebe Demissew, Gwilym Lewis, Brian Schrire, Lourdes Rico, Abraham E. van Wyk
TAXON  vol: 59  issue: 4  first page: 1188  year: 2010  
doi: 10.1002/tax.594017

18. Conserving Acacia Mill. with a conserved type: What happened in Melbourne?
Gideon F. Smith, Estrela Figueiredo
TAXON  vol: 60  issue: 5  first page: 1504  year: 2011  
doi: 10.1002/tax.605033

19. The fate of Acacia
H. Peter Linder, Mike Crisp
TAXON  vol: 60  issue: 2  first page: 570  year: 2011  
doi: 10.1002/tax.602023